Search or add a thesis

Advanced Search (Beta)
Home > Wholistic Management Education Wme : Contextualized Applicability of Transformative Learning in Management Education Discourse

Wholistic Management Education Wme : Contextualized Applicability of Transformative Learning in Management Education Discourse

Thesis Info

Access Option

External Link

Author

Yazdani, Naveed

Program

PhD

Institute

University of Management and Technology

City

Lahore

Province

Punjab

Country

Pakistan

Thesis Completing Year

2018

Thesis Completion Status

Completed

Subject

Bussiness & Management

Language

English

Link

http://prr.hec.gov.pk/jspui/bitstream/123456789/12589/1/Naveed%20yazdani%20management%202018.pdf

Added

2021-02-17 19:49:13

Modified

2024-03-24 20:25:49

ARI ID

1676725171013

Asian Research Index Whatsapp Chanel
Asian Research Index Whatsapp Chanel

Join our Whatsapp Channel to get regular updates.

Similar


This thesis is a critical exploration of traditional management education discourse. It advocates imparting transformative business education leading to ‘whole person’ learning of business students. Traditional management education needs transformation because it is in crisis. The prestigious management education journal Academy of Management Learning & Education is leading a wave of scathing criticism on different aspects of business school education for the last decade or so. The most critiqued of these aspects include inability of traditional business school education to prepare students to face real world complexities. This is attributed to management education pedagogy’s over-reliance on science and rationality leading to short term profit focus and its being oblivious to larger issues of society, context, values and history. A majority of previous research involves application of Mezirow’s transformative learning theory in non-management settings. This thesis combines Mezirow’s cognitive perspective of transformation with later developments including extra-rational thinking, multiple ways of knowing and the ability to critically evaluate social and organizational dynamics to presents the concept of ‘wholistic management education’ (WME). Based on contemporary scholarly critique on management education, UNESCO Curricular Reforms Manifesto (2011), Principles of Responsible Management Education (PRME) (2011) and guidelines of Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan (2012) the thesis constructs five ‘missing’ discourses of management education. These discourses serve as foundations for developing WME model of the thesis. This model not only captures the micro level discursive interplay between business school texts and actions but also connects it with the macro discourse’s proximal and distal structures like organizations, society and environment. From WME discourse construction the thesis turns to critical analysis of traditional management education discourse by incorporating extra-linguistic factors such as power relations, dominance, history, ideology and hegemony inherent in it. The five main discourses are constructed on the basis of carefully and systematically selected management education and transformative learning literature. The main proponents of different perspectives of transformative learning are identified on the basis of number of well received books authored/edited (the cut-off point is at least 4 well received books) and their publications in IF Journals. For selecting literature of management education it is ensured to include the main writers highlighting different gaps in management education over the last 15 years. Academy of Management Learning & Education is the main source for selecting frequently cited articles on management education critique. More than 100 such articles were short listed for abstract reviews. Those found relevant with research objectives and questions of this thesis were reviewed thoroughly. Some of the books mentioned in the References of the selected articles were shortlisted and their Introductions and Prefaces were read. Those resonating with the research aims of the thesis were given detailed reading. The same criterion of identifying influential authors is employed as in the case of transformative learning literature. The thesis creates nuance in transformative learning and management education research by positing them as discourses and also through the application of critical discourse analysis on business education. The construction of WME discourse and critical analysis of traditional management education discourse reveal that history of Western civilization has a reflexive relation with history of management education which in turn has shaped the overall discourse of business education. Similarly Civilizational values have played an important role in shaping different historic-philosophical epochs of Western civilization which have influenced the development of cultural and organizational values manifesting as organizing practices institutionalizing and reinforcing the legitimacy of management education texts. The strong reflexive relation of management education with this ‘value hierarchy’ creates the notion of ‘universalism’ through which traditional business education implicitly suppresses local non-Western contexts and epistemologies. The micro-micro and micro-macro intertextuality-based discourse relations emerging through applying the proposed WME model are shown to counter this suppression and to encourage developing whole person learning in business students enabling them to face the ambiguities and complexities of their respective real worlds. The thesis not only pioneers the application of extra-linguistic critical discourse analysis techniques on management education but also advances transformative learning theory towards a more unified, contextualized and wholistic perspective. The major scholarly value of this thesis is production of a contextualized ‘counter-discourse’ to the universal traditional management education discourse.
Loading...
Loading...

Similar Books

Loading...

Similar Chapters

Loading...

Similar News

Loading...

Similar Articles

Loading...

Similar Article Headings

Loading...

جامعہ الازہر میں اردو شناسی

جامعہ الازہر میں اردو شناسی

مصر میں ہمارا آخری پڑائو جامعہ الازہر تھا ۔میرے خیال میں مصر کی تاریخ جامعہ الازہر کے بغیر نامکمل ہے ۔دس لاکھ بشمول پچاس ہزار غیر ملکی طالب علموں کی علمی آبیاری کر نے والے اس ادارے کو دیکھنا اور وہاں کے اساتذہ اور طلبہ سے مصاحبہ اور مکالمہ کرنا مسافر کی بڑ ی آرزو تھی۔ پوری مسلم امہ میں شاید یہ واحد بڑی درسگاہ ہے جہاں لگ بھگ سات درجن شعبہ جات میں دینی اور دنیوی علوم کی تدریس ہوتی ہے ۔میں نے دکتور محمود سے پوچھا کہ کون سے بڑے علو م ہیںجو یہاں پڑھائے جاتے ہیں ۔انھوں نے برجستہ کہا سارے علوم ۔انھوں نے پھر وضاحت کی کہ دینی علوم تو ہیں سارے اس کے علاوہ ہندسہ،طب ،معاشیات ،بنکاری ، تجارت ، تاریخ ، تصوف،ادب،ارضیات،عمرانیات،تہذیب اور سائنس غرض بہت سارے علوم ہیں ۔ دکتور محمود نے علم و فنون کا طویل پہاڑ ا ایک سانس میں سنا دیا ۔میں نے ان سے پوچھا کہ اس طویل فہرست میں آپ نے اس شعبے کا نام نہیں لیا جہاں جانا میری خواہش ہے ۔ ہنس کر کہنے لگے ’’اردو‘‘جی بالکل جامعہ ا لازہر ہی نہیں بلکہ مصر کی چھے سات جامعات میں شعبہ اردو ہے ۔

ہم جامعہ کے صدر دروازے سے داخل ہوئے جس پر جلی حروف میں ’’جامعہ الازہر فرع البنات ‘‘لکھا تھا گیٹ پر ضروری سیکورٹی کلیرنس کے بعد ہمیں شعبہ اردو کی طرف جانے کی اجازت دے دی گئی ۔ہم شعبہ اردو کی طرف جا ہی رہے تھے کہ ایک طالبہ دوڑتی ہوئے ہمارے پاس آئی اور عربی آمیز اردو لہجے میں مخاطب ہوئی کہ ’’آپ لوگ پاکستان سے آئے ہیں ؟‘‘دکتور ابراہیم اپنے دفتر میں آپ کا انتظار کر رہے ہیں ۔‘‘ہم ان کے ساتھ ہو لیے اور صدر شعبہ...

الإمام زفر: أصوله الفقهية وآرائه المفتي بها في تفسير الأحكام

Compilation and codification of Islamic jurisprudence is a great achievement of the Islamic literary history. The productivity andfertility of the mind of the Muslims Scholars was a true and brilliant field of cognitive process. Ilanafi school of thought display in these Muslims societies from practice point of view always dominated. In this respect the Imam Zufar (RA) (110AH) had been a great scholar in Ilanafi Canon with his unique multi-dimensional features and characteristics. Nevertheless, He iras a prominent jurist, Muhaddis, Justice and Mujtahid. He paved a different path to have difference of opinion with his great teacher Imam Abu Hanifa as well as with the rest offamous jurists. This article emphasis on those principles along with examples that at the end evolved to have become his exclusive principles for inference of the Shari. ahka am. This article will also highlight his versatile scholary life and will help the researchers to investigate about his seminal work.

The Impact of Perceived Service Fairness on Customer Citizenship Behaviors: the Mediating Role of Relationship Marketing

Since late 1980’s the banking sector in Pakistan has undergone major structural changes due to financial liberalization and deregulations. This transformation has led to greater competition among financial institutions, favoring in the efficiency and competitiveness of banking sector. As a result, a greater variety and choices of products and services for customers are available while some banking institutions are offering sophisticated delivery systems and more value-added services than rivals. Likewise, banks have also come under enormous pressure to tackle the growing demands and expectations of their consumers as well as due to the shift in customer-centric regulatory paradigm towards protection of financial consumers, posing major challenge for bank to retain existing customers. These considerations converge to imply the need for more specific customer-focused strategies to build and maintain enduring bankclient relationships. Presently, the business environment surrounding banking institution is highly competitive where new clients are hard to attract at mature stage in their life cycles, hence banks must strive for establishing new revenue streams,, particularly in a situation where competition between financial establishments has intensified, banking institutions need to make various efforts to achieve differentiated competitiveness through forging sustainable relationships with customers. In terms of producers of financial services, considering the highly competitive nature of banking industry and increasingly interactive customer roles, fairness in service delivery is essential in developing and maintaining bank-client relationships. Earlier studies show that a consumer''s perception of whether a service provider has fulfilled the obligation to deliver the desired outcome and benefits associated with the service promised to consumers serve as a is a fundamental basis for sustaining and enhancing long-term customer-firm relationships. Service fairness is a multidimensional construct composed of distributive fairness, procedural fairness, informational and interactional fairness, which refers to a consumer’s perception regarding the degree of justice in a service provider’s behavior during service delivery process. Service fairness is an implicit agreement between customers with their service providers to have their needs served well and to be treated fairly according the service outcomes promised. Successful customer relationship management can be attributed to a customer’s positive evaluations of a service provider’s efforts in provision of service fairness excellence during an exchange relationship. Although banking services is recognized to encounter numerous service failure episodes there has been scant investigations in commercial banking sector of Pakistan that addressed the connection among service fairness, relationship marketing and customer engagement. Past studies in the domain relationship marketing strongly support that mutually profitable buyer-seller relationships are key to secure competitive advantage emphasizing the importance of quality and value of relationships. However, there is a lack of an integrative perspective about understanding buyer-seller relationship building process through the lens of service fairness. This research contributes to building a comprehensive understanding on how customer evaluations regarding different facets of service fairness affect bankconsumer relationship building process and lead customers to perform various citizenship behaviors, by examining empirically this relationship at multi-group level. This research study was conducted in Pakistan, using a positivist philosophical lens, data was gathered quantitively with the help of questionnaire distributed using stratified random sampling technique. The validity of survey instrument and structural paths relationships were confirmed using pilot study procedure. The results of pilot survey were very useful in validating the proposed model and measurement scales used in the study however few of the items were dropped from subsequent analysis to improve the reliability and validity of the instrument. Data was gathered from 1740 consumers of banking services located within scheduled bank branches in a single cross-section however only 1430 valid responses were subjected to further analysis. The model was assessed using partial least square based Structured Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM), using Smart PLS 3.2.7 statistical software following the PLS-SEM guidelines proposed by (Jörg Henseler, Hubona, & Ray, 2017) in the field of social sciences research. As a result, the model demonstrated greater predictive response to a consumer’s assessment of service fairness. The results of this research confirmed that banking consumers commonly evaluate fairness in exchange relationships when dealing with service providers. The findings support the model’s structure and indicated that all four dimensions of service fairness determine relationship value and quality, which in turn lead customers to perform citizenship behaviors. The results show that service fairness evaluations also had direct influence on customer citizenship behavior, however this relationship is better explained by a firm’s relationship marketing efforts. This implies that although fair treatment is essential in reinforcing long-term relationships and for customers to engage in citizenship behaviors but it is also a significant condition that may encourage consumers to perform positive extra role behavioral outcomes. Therefore, banks should provide assurance that their services can achieve a sustainable level of favorableness that meets what the service provider has promised to its customers. This study brought to light that the knowledge pertaining to the critical role of service fairness strategies in building valuable, enduring relationships with customers. Moreover, this research contributes in the relationship marketing literature on how service fairness excellence encourage customer to engage in citizenship behaviors in favor of the firm through developing successful long-term mutually beneficial relationship. Therefore, besides service excellence banks need focus on providing excellence in service fairness to create strong relationships with their clients as endured relationship can lead to customer citizenship behaviors.