Search or add a thesis

Advanced Search (Beta)
Home > Religious Encounters and Religious Pluralism in the Nineteenth Century Bengal: A Contextualized Study of Swami Vivekanandas Neo-Vedanta

Religious Encounters and Religious Pluralism in the Nineteenth Century Bengal: A Contextualized Study of Swami Vivekanandas Neo-Vedanta

Thesis Info

Access Option

External Link

Author

Zaheer, Nosheen

Program

PhD

Institute

International Islamic University

City

Islamabad

Province

Islamabad.

Country

Pakistan

Thesis Completing Year

2016

Thesis Completion Status

Completed

Subject

Comparative Religion

Language

English

Link

http://prr.hec.gov.pk/jspui/bitstream/123456789/12671/1/Nosheen%20Zaheer_Comparative%20Religion_2016_IIU_PRR.pdf

Added

2021-02-17 19:49:13

Modified

2024-03-24 20:25:49

ARI ID

1676725334009

Asian Research Index Whatsapp Chanel
Asian Research Index Whatsapp Chanel

Join our Whatsapp Channel to get regular updates.

Similar


This doctoral dissertation consists of an introduction, five chapters and conclusion. The introduction is designed to focus on Vivekananda’s biographical details by relying on available literature. An account of his life further enables researcher to highlight the contribution of his predecessor’s neo-Vedantins in shaping his practical Vedanta. Among these neo-Vedantins the role and nature of Ram Mohan Roy’s and Ramakrishna’s neo-Vedanta is briefly discussed in the context of nineteenth century pluralistic Bengali society. A few pages are also written on neo-Vedanta of Vivekananda that made its appearance in the second half of the nineteenth century in Bengal due to the amalgamation of Ram Mohan’s western influenced neo-Vedanta and Ramakrishna’s mystical neo-Vedanta. The investigation of the distinct nature of his neo-Vedanta, his doctrine of religious pluralism and Universalism and contextualized study of his neo-Vedanta research frame is developed. That constitutes the theory of pluralism and Karl Mannheim approach of sociology of knowledge. The first chapter deals with the background of religious reform movements in the nineteenth century Bengal that are restricted to Farāʼḍῑ movement and neo-Vedantic movements (of Ram Mohan Roy and Ramakrishna). These reform movements emerged to inculcate religious consciousness for reforming and revitalizing their respective religions; Hinduism and Islam. Farāʼḍῑ, Muslim reform movement, considered revitalization of Islam in taking refuge in the golden period of Prophet Muḥammad while neo-Vedanat, Hindu reform movement, believed in the revival of Hinduism by reinterpreting Hinduism in rational and western philosophical framework to neutralize Christian criticism. Hājῑ Sharῑ‘atullah (1787-1840), as a Muslim reformer expressed his core objective in underlining the Islamic five basic obligations to establish a Muslim society on the footsteps of Prophet Muḥammad by eradicating all types of shirk (polytheism) and innovations. While, in Hinduism Ram Mohan Roy’s apologetic approach gave birth to neo-Vedanta. Ram Mohan tried to equate his neo-Vedanta with Advaita Vedanta when he claimed that he had approved Advaita Vedanta, the only creed of his Brahmo Samaj, but the reality reflects another side of the picture. Because in Ram Mohan neo-Vedanta metaphysical spirituality of Advaita Vedanta’s was substituted by western intellectuality and reasoning to reject the authority of Vedas, Idol worship, caste system, widow burning and caste discrimination. Ramakrishna’s neo-Vedanta succeeded in maintaining the link with Indian mystical elements firstly, due to his bhagti for mother Kali and secondly, he never experienced direct contact with western secular education. On the contrary, to Ram Mohan’s neo-Vedanta, he supported Idol worshiping, rejected the caste system while he was silent on sati. He criticized the Ram Mohan’s apologetic attitude towards Hinduism because he considered Hinduism beyond any corruption and ignorance. He rather emphasized on the infiniteness of Hinduism, which, according to him, had the ability to accommodate all ranges of worship, from polytheism to monotheism. His neo-Vedanta appears to be tantra Advaita Vedanta due to his preference of bhagti over janan that made him to equate his Kali to metaphysical impersonal Brahman and in his tantric context, the world became lila of his mother Kali. His experiential neo-Vedanta in non-Hindu religious experiences gave him syncretic vision, which considered all religions as different paths leading to one goal; realization of one God. But his every religious experience of other non-Hindu religions attained its climax in his nirguna and saguna Brahman. In the nineteenth century Bengali society the catalyst behind this religious Renaissance was the late eighteenth century Orientalists generally, and nineteenth century Christian missionaries particularly. Though the methodologies these two adopted were opposite in nature. The Orientalists produced the feeling of pride in Hindus is regarding their religion, while the Missionaries targeted those Hindu beliefs and practices through which they could sow the seed of inferiority complexes among the Hindus. The above mentioned brief historical background of the nineteenth century reform movements generally and neo- Vedantins particular, provides the foundation for the second chapter of this dissertation; Vivekananda’s neo-Vedanta. This chapter mainly discusses the practical implementation of neo-Vedanta in the context of caste system, liberation of Hindu women from unjust socio-religious practices and missionary Hinduism. The key through which Vivekananda tried to interpret these issues was his new scheme of metaphysics (neo-Vedanta) that he developed by bringing Impersonal metaphysical Brahman of Shankaracharya to the mayic world. This penetration not only facilitated him to postulate the concept of a deified world where the jiva becomes Shiva and worship of God becomes parallel with service of humanity. In this deified Vivekananda’s world, men and women of all castes become equal due to equal sharing of divinity and it leaves no space for caste and gender discrimination. Beside these issues in this chapter, Vivekananda’s concept of missionary Hinduism is also discussed. He satisfied his missionary zeal by merging Buddhism with Hinduism because according to him Buddhism is nothing else but spiritual Hinduism. His intentions behind this melting of Buddhist boundary in Hinduism was on the one hand to regain those Hindus into Hinduism who converted to other religions and to check the mass conversion of Hindus to Christianity. On the other hand, his missionary axiom of absorption of good from other religions and to keep intact once religious identity provided him the impetus to formulate his neo-Vedanta in the pluralistic and universalistic realm. Therefore the third chapter with the title, The Journey of Vivekananda from Revival and Reform to Pluralism and Universalism aims at focusing on how Vivekananda perceived Hinduism among other world religions, as well as how he defines the term religion, types of religion and purpose of religion! Vivekananda’s writing is missing one single definition of religion; he rather defines religion differently in different sections of his work. His every definition, however, in one way or another, is pointing towards Hinduism generally and Vedanta particularly. His categorizations of world religions are also based on the realization of God in the soul (Vedanta) that enables him categorize religion in semantic religion and Vedanta. While as a pluralist his position at some place appears as an inclusivist, and on other occasions as an exclusivist. His inclusivism becomes evident when on the one hand; he accommodates Islam and Christianity in Dvaita Vedanta,and symbolic Christ as living Vedantins. While his religious exclusivism can be noticed in placing Vedanta as a universal religion, because it can fulfill the spiritual thirst of a variety of people due to bhagti, Jnana and karma margas. Vivekananda’s adjustment of non-Hindu religion in Vedantic frame demands exploration of his knowledge regarding other non-Hindu religions (Buddhism, Christianity and Islam). Hence Chapter four, Vivekananda’s Views about other Religions is divided into three subsections; each describes his treatment of Buddhism, Christianity and Islam regarding their religious doctrines, founders or prophets and as a civilization. It is interesting to note that his whole appreciation, criticism or rejection of the religious doctrines and religious practices of these religions was done within Vedantic frame. Or in other words Vedanta was a standard set of Vivekananda for the acceptance or rejection of other non-Hindu religions. Among these non-Hindu religions his fondness and preference for Hinduism becomes more evident in evaluating Islam as a religion when it is compared with other religions. This is because he tried to reject Islamic tenets not only through Vedanta, but also through depending on prevalent Muslim practices. He writes that Islam claims to be a monotheistic religion, but polytheism is widely spread is Islamic practices, like Muslims’ prostration to the Kabah, their kissing of the black stone and reverence to a Pīr’s grave. These four chapters of the thesis lead the researcher to the last chapter that attempted a contextual study of Vivekananda’s neo-Vedanta. The fifth chapter entitled Contextualized Interpretation of the Vivekananda’s neo-Vedantais intended to understand the effects and the relationship of the Orientalists, Christian missionaries and his neo-Vedantin predecessors in shaping his practical Vedanta in the nineteenth century Bengal. Among these Orientalists and Missionaries, the trio of William Edward, Colebrook, Serampore and Alexander Duff are worth mentioning. While among his predecessors, the earlier efforts of Ram Mohan Roy, Debendra Nath Tagore, Keshab Chandra and Ramakrishna have been addressed. The conclusion pertains to the results of the study." xml:lang="en_US
Loading...
Loading...

Similar Books

Loading...

Similar Chapters

Loading...

Similar News

Loading...

Similar Articles

Loading...

Similar Article Headings

Loading...

یہ ستم کس لیے اب خود پہ نہ ڈھایا جائے

یہ ستم کس لیے اب خود پہ نہ ڈھایا جائے
دل سے وہ وعدہ فراموش بھلایا جائے
تلخ یادوں کو تلف کرنا ہے لازم ٹھہرا
ہر ورق مصحفِ ہستی کا جلایا جائے

The Pandemic Era Digital Economy: Youth Challenges in Social Media Marketing

The field of finance, fintech, and even finance companies like insurers has become part of the world of the internet. Indeed, the digital economy has now entered the areas of shipping, banking, agriculture and urban planning. This is characterized by the usage of technologies and the internet for various uses, including digitalization, of culture. Hence the improvements in the organizational and even marketing processes to the customer element level and numerous transactional regulatory structures is important and common in industries. Youth are also facing challenges in social network marketing, including reliance on technological development, safety and privacy issues, balanced personalization and privacy, marketing transparency, uneven Internet infrastructure in ASEAN Countries, and tight competition. This is an important aspect of the youth's efforts.

Mitochondrial Membrane Potential Regulatory Genes and Respective Mirnas Role in Valvular Heart Disease

Valvular Heart Disease (VHD) is the third common cause of deaths worldwide. It increases the risk of human morbidity and mortality in developing countries including Pakistan. Stenosis and regurgitation are the major cause of valve dysfunctions. Calcification of aortic valve characterized by both pathological conditions was found mostly in elder ages. However, calcification in bicuspid aortic valve (BAV) characterized by stenosis occurred in 1% of the total cases of valve dysfunction. Rheumatic Heart Disease (RHD) was also found as one of the leading cause of valve dysfunction mostly in teenage. The total incident of RHD in females was observed higher than males. In addition, the total number of post Closed Mitral Valvatomy (CMVs) cases and the patients having history of genetic cardiac complications were also high in females when compared with male patients. The poor life style in Pakistan is highly associated with distinct heart complications including RHD. The use of tobacco (snuff and smoking) might also be the risk factors of various cardiac complication including VHD found mostly in males as compared to females. The redox potential is essential for cardiomyocytes cellular processes and their survival. Cellular stress in cardiomyocyte induce uncontrolled cell proliferation or excessive cell loss which leads to the development of various cardiac complications including VHD and IHD. To date, numerous clinical and animal model studies revealed that cellular stress regarding depolarization of mitochondrial membrane regulatory factors are the leading cause of cardiomyocytes loss through the process of apoptosis. microRNAs are also the key regulators of mitochondrial membrane regulatory genes. However, the cellular stress alters expression levels can directly or indirectly change the expression of various genes both at transcription and translation level during disease progression. This study proposed that miR-15a and miR-29a were downregulated while the expression of miR-214 was upregulated in the VHD human tissues during disease. Cardiomyocytes homeostasis is maintained by the balanced expression of mitochondrial apoptotic and anti-apoptotic whereas altered mitochondrial integrity may lead to cardiomyocytes apoptosis. In the present study, low expression of miR-15a and miR-29a might be related to upregulation of PUMA and DRP1. On the other hand, ARC might be repressed as a result of miR-214 overexpression. In addition, expression studies revealed that miR-15a targets mitochondrial apoptotic gene PUMA however, miR-214 targets anti-apoptotic gene ARC. The extensive free radical generation and their accumulation cause oxidative stress which also contributes in prognosis of various cardiovascular diseases including VHD and IHD. The persistence of cardiomyocytes oxidative stress due to decrease antioxidant enzymatic activity may further leads to damage in cardiomyocytes. Our finding also confirmed that increase in ROS with low antioxidant enzymatic activities were also the suggested reasons of VHD. Furthermore, GATA-4 was also downregulated in the disease conditions of both aortic and mitral valves. Based on these notions, low level of GATA-4 expression has been previously documented with high rate of apoptosis in cardiac cells which leads to various cardiac disorders. Our present study highlights miRNAs that can control the expression of mitochondrial apoptotic and anti-apoptotic regulatory genes, these mRNAs may be the potential candidates for molecular medicines for treating VHD in future. Furthermore, significantly high level of NT- proBNP was observed in all pathological conditions of aortic valve that showed the severity of valvular pathology. However, the uric acid level was mildly high in aortic stenosis. Ischemic Heart Disease (IHD) is also the major cause of death globally is characterized by reduced supply of blood. Restoration of blood supply to the ischemic part can also results in cardiomyocytes loss due to ischemic/ Reperfusion injury (IRI). Recently, a newly introduced therapeutic strategy known as remote ischemic preconditioning (RIPC) can be used to protect cardiac cells from IRI by releasing a large number of exosomes. The detail mechanism of cardioprotective activity of exosomes is still not fully clear which needs to be further investigated. In-vitro analysis of neonatal rats cardiomyocyte cells (NRCM) treated with ischemic preconditioning (IPC) procedure showed that miR-133a, miR-133b and miR-24 were highly expressed both at exosomal and cellular levels which may also have the cardioprotective effects. In summary, many cardiac complications including VHD and IHD are accompanied withhigh oxidative stress. The persistent high oxidative stress might be due to excessive ROS and depletion of antioxidant enzymes. This phenomena may alter the expression of mitochondrial membrane regulatory genes which ultimately leads to cells loss (apoptosis). In addition, microRNAs can also be used as a therapeutic intervention for survival of cardiomyocytes during various cardiac complications including VHD and IHD.