Home > New Insight into the Levels, Distribution and Risk Diagnosis of Flame Retardants Frs in Potable Water, Air and Dust from Different Altitudinal Zones of Pakistan
New Insight into the Levels, Distribution and Risk Diagnosis of Flame Retardants Frs in Potable Water, Air and Dust from Different Altitudinal Zones of Pakistan
Currently limited information/knowledge is available about the occurrence, sources and distribution of flame retardants (FRs) in the potable water, air and dust as well as their associated health risk to the exposed human population. This is the first study designed to probe selected flame retardants (FRs) in the indoor and outdoor air and dust as well as potable water samples at different altitudinal zones (industrial, rural and background) of Pakistan with special emphasis upon their occurrence, distribution and associated health risk diagnosis. Therefore, the selected FRs viz., Polybrominated diphenylethers (PBDEs), Dechlorane plus (DP), Novel brominated flame retardants (NBFRs) and Organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs)) in a total of 38 air (indoor and outdoor), 82 dust (indoor and outdoor) and 39 potable water samples were collected from different altitudinal zones. The targeted FRs were analyzed by Gas chromatograph Agilent 7890A coupled to mass spectrometer (5973C MSD) in electron capture negative ionization (ECNI) and GC/MS-MS Agilent 7000A triple Quad operating in Selective ion mode (SIM). Results for the targeted FRs in the air (indoor and outdoor) samples collected from different altitudinal zones showed the trends as: ΣNBFRs > ΣPBDEs > ΣDP, While for the dust (indoor and outdoor) samples were ranked: ΣOPFRs > ΣNBFRs > ΣPBDEs > ΣDP. Significant correlation among FRs in the indoor and outdoor air at different altitudinal zones suggested similar source origin of FRs used in different consumer goods. Significant correlation in the FRs levels between the indoor and outdoor dust suggested the potential intermixing of these compounds between different environmental matrices. Similarly, Principal component analysis (PCA)/Multiple linear regression (MLR) predicted the percent contribution of FRs from different consumer products in the indoor and outdoor dust of industrial, rural and background zones to trace their source origin. Furthermore, air mass trajectories for air samples revealed that movement of air over industrial area sources influenced concentrations of FRs at rural sites. While, for dust samples, the forward and backward air mass trajectories showed that the FRs detected in the background zones reveal the dust-bound FRs suspended in the air might be shifted from different warmer zones or consumers products available/used in the same zones. Elevated concentrations of FRs in the potable water samples were revealed in the industrial zones followed by rural and background zones, while the decreasing trends for FRs in the potable water samples highlighted were: ΣOPFRs > ΣPBDEs > ΣNBFRs > ΣDP due to the much higher water solubility for OPFRs as compared to the other BFRs. Among the analyzed FRs, Tris-(2-chloroisopropyl)-phosphate (ΣTCPP), anti-DP, BDE-47 and 1,2- bis(pentabromodiphenyl)ethane (DBDPE) were the dominant compounds in three selected zones. Principal component analysis (PCA) revealed that most of the FRs are associated with the industrial zones. It is suggested that FRs might be leached out from wastewater bodies and subsequently mixed with nearby potable water facilities. FRs may also spill out from the aluminum or plastic pipes and tanks most commonly used for potable water storage in Pakistan. xv The FRs concentrations, estimated daily intake (EDI) and the hazard quotient (HQ) in potable water, air and dust samples were recorded higher in toddlers as compared to adults. Moreover, the indoor air and dust samples showed higher FRs levels, EDI and HQ than outdoor air and dust samples. It was found that in air, dust and potable water samples an elevated FRs concentrations, EDI and HQ were recorded in the industrial zones followed by rural and background zones. HQs for FRs in the Children/toddlers and adults via potable water consumption and indoor and outdoor dust were <1 highlighting no risk to the vulnerable population. While on the other hand, the HQ values >1 in toddlers and adults population warrants a health risk for BDE-47 and -99 in most of the indoor and outdoor air samples at the industrial zones; while for BDE-47 in the toddlers at indoor and outdoor air samples in some sites at the rural zones of Gujrat and Gujranwala, Pakistan. The results of this study will provide a baseline record for FRs (PBDEs, DP, NBFRs and OPFRs) concentrations in the indoor and outdoor air, dust and potable water at different altitudinal zones in Pakistan. Strict implementations in regard of FRs associated products are needed to minimize the future health concerns through FRs exposure. Alternative products should be introduced to reduce the hazards from FRs. Furthermore, detailed studies are required to assess the long range transport of FRs and modeling approaches for better understanding of their distribution in different environmental compartments. Key words: Flame retardants, Air, Dust, Potable water, Exposure pathways, Pakistan
حضور بابا پیر سید ولی محمد شاہ سائیں رحمۃ اللہ علیہ (آف پیر شاہ والے ) میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی توں ایں مولا علی دا وزیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی آلِ نبی، اولادِ علی ایں، پائی شان نرالی توں جو وی آیا در تیرے تے گھلیا نہ کوئی خالی توں کوہجھیاں نوں گل لا کے سائیاں لگیاں دی لج پالی توں میری معاف کریں تقصیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی اہل علاقہ گھر گھر سائیاں تیرے دیوے بلدے شان انہاں دی پچھنی کی جیہڑے تیری سنگت رلدے ناں تیرا ہک وار جے لیّے ساڈڑے دکھڑے ٹلدے شعلہ پیر تیری تصویر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی ولیاں دا سرتاج سداویں تیرے شان نرالے نیں تیرے منن والے سائیاں ہر جا رہن سوکھالے نیں ایڈ سخاوت ہور نہ کوئی، بن منگیوں بھرے پیالے نیں دیویں درشن کامل پیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی
سیاں نے دربار تیرے تے جھرمٹ ویکھو پایا ہجر فراق تیرے وچ سیاں رو رو حال ونجایا جنہاں سک مرشد دی رکھی اوہناں درشن پایا دیویں صدقہ بدر منیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی کیتھل پیر دا فیض روحانی شہر قبولے آیا اے مئے نوشاں نوں دستگیرؒ سائیں بھر بھر جام پلایا اے بابے پیر ولی شاہؒ تے تاں ہوکا پیا دیوایا اے تیرے در دا بناں فقیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی میری بدل دیویں تقدیر ولی شاہ باباؒ جی پیر مبشر پوتا سائیں دا بڑیاں شاناں والا مہر محبت ایڈی اس وچ ہر دا پچھے حالا صورت سیرت دادے والی سب نوں دیوے سنبھالا ہویا قادریؔ زلف اسیر ولی...
Penelitian ini dilaksanakan di Program Studi S1 Manajemen UIN Suska Riau dan Program Studi S1 Manajemen UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung , Penelitian ini menggunakan metode Komparatif membandingkan dua gejalan pada objek yang berbeda,dalam penelitian ini jumlah sampel sebesar 96 responden yaitu masing masing 48 sampel adalah mahasiswa program studi S1 Manajemen UIN Suska Riau dan 48 sampel adalah mahasiswa program studi S1 Manajemen UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung, Nilai R2 ( R Square ) Mahasiswa Program Studi S1 Manajemen 0.490 atau 49 % dan Nilai R2 ( R Square ) Mahasiswa Program Studi S1 Manajemen UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung. Saran dalam penelitian ini bahwa seharusnya mahasiswa UIN Suska Riau lebih bijak menggunakan fasilitas internet dan sebaiknya kecanduang internat pada mahasiswa UIN Bandung digunakan untuk meningkatkan motivasi belajar dan untuk kegiatan bisnis seperti bisnis online yang sangat menarik dalam prospek bisnis di era digitalisasi sekarang.
Contextualized text means the text resulting from the local circumstances and in accordance with learners’ needs and cognition level. It also suggests that the text in use includes language, understandable to the target learners, and suits the philosophy and psychology of the learners and the society. Knowledge shifts from one to another context more successfully when the pupil understands not only the specifics but also the generalized vision—the fundamental ideology, models, and associations attained through the appliance of comprehension. True experimental design was adopted for the research to explain the relationship between dependent and independent variables. Two groups (control and experimental) were selected randomly to conduct the experiment. The independent variable of the study was Contextualized text and dependent variables were Writing Skills, Thinking Skills and Social and Ethical Development of the learners while learners’ Socioeconomic Status was taken as an attribute variable. The researcher selected simple factorial design for the study to analyze the effects of attribute variable as well on the dependent variables. Descriptive statistics was used to convert the data from mere wordy data into statistical one in order to make it measurable and statistically provable. ANOVA was used to make credible inferences from the data obtained. The findings signify that improvement in students’ learning is because of the treatment and no other factor has any effect on this.